Read all that happened when Supreme Court heard PIL to ban ‘Sardar jokes’

sikh-897859_640As was first reported by 1, Law Street yesterday, a bench of the Supreme Court of India today heard a PIL petition which sought ban on the ‘Sardar/Sikh’ jokes’. Petition has inter alia made the following prayer:

issue a writ of mandamus to the respondents to ban websites spreading jokes on sardars/Sikhs projecting them as persons of low intellect, stupid and foolish, etc.

Listed at item 48, when the matter was called, petitioner Harvinder Chowdhury, a practising advocate, appeared in person and informed the bench that she required some further time to file certain volumes of documents in the matter.

Justice Thakur who was presiding the bench which also comprised of Justice V Gopala Gowda, appeared to be little amused and said:

Sikh community is known for their sense of humour and they themselves might object to this petition.

Justice Thakur also said that Khushwant Singh had himself written a book on Sardar jokes. The petitioner however told Court that she was aware that the petition was very strange but she was prepared to answer that question. She said that the jokes made on Sikhs have led to them being ridiculed across the globe. She cited certain examples from her personal knowledge where a patient embarrassed a Sikh Doctor after his treatment. She also cited her personal experience where a lawyer in the bar rooms had cracked a joke saying “aapke 12 baj gaye.”

Petitioner told Court that she was once embarrassed by an airport personnel on her being late for the flight with remarks like “kar di naa sardaron waali baat”. She further said that the Sikh children do not like to have ‘singh’ suffixed to their names as it shows their identity.

Referring to Justice JS Kehar, Justice Thakur remarked that the Supreme Court was fortunate to have a Sikh judge with itself and said that this petition can be sent to him. However the petitioner disagreed with this suggestion and asked the bench not to do so.


Court asks Sr. Counsel Singhvi for his opinion

During the course of hearing, Justice Thakur turned to Senior Counsel Abhishek Manu Singhvi who sitting in the front row was waiting for his matter, asking him of his opinion. Mr. Singhvi then rose and said:

Poland would be poor without Polish jokes and India would be poor without Sikh jokes.


Petitioner seeks one hour to argue her case

Petitioner asserted that the matter was of grave importance and hence she requires a substantial times to argue the case. She sought permission to file additional documents and requested that she then be given at least an hour’s time to argue the case.


As a mark of respect, Court dictates petitioner’s name in the order

Petitioner told Court that once she had argued a case before a certain Supreme Court judge who after the matter called out her name in the open court and praised her for her presentation of the case. On this Justice Thakur said “today also we will say your name” and then turned to the court master and dictated the order starting with the name of the appearing petitioner-in-person.

The matter has been adjourned for six weeks for the petitioner to file additional documents and will be taken up next on January 4, 2016.

4 Comments

  1. I fully support this petition because almost people don’t miss any single chance make to insult any sikh person.

  2. Yes, agree with petition the persons who remembers for their glorious history and sacrifice , we will not allow any body to make joke on them.

  3. yes jokes on sikh should be banned i was in IAF for 20 years i know how my family and children have tolerated the jokes on sardar/////////// It shameful for other community to insult the children and family of a sikh person………… being minority you cannot fight with them

  4. Thanks to the petitioner to bring up this issue.The joke crackers why can’t give the motivational and bravery examples of Sikhs instead of using insulting and low profile examples. If u wants to enjoy jokes, you can use the subject as A and B instead of mentioning particular name of one race. Please keep in mind today we all are because of Sikhs unconditional sacrifices, otherwise we could have been converted in to Muslim as there is written on the first page of book ” Sah a Kamaal Guru Gobind Singh by the Lala Daulat RAI ” Na kahoon abb Ki Na Kahoon tab ki, Agar Na hote Guru Gobind Singh to sunnad Hoti Sab Ki.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *